Wood siding on a heritage Sandy Hill house, repair or replace?
Wood siding on a heritage Sandy Hill house, repair or replace?
If the house is designated or in a Heritage Conservation District, the repair-versus-replace decision is not only a materials question. Changing the siding on a designated heritage property, or one in a Heritage Conservation District, requires City approval under the Ontario Heritage Act before work begins that could affect heritage attributes. Talk to the City's heritage staff before you choose a direction, and ask the City's Building Code Services whether a building permit is also required. The City's permit pages do not list siding either way, and heritage buildings are not covered by any permit exemption.
On the repair side, the 2024 Ontario Building Code's renovation provisions (Part 11) treat existing cladding as acceptable under compliance alternative C196, so the original wood that stays can stay as it is; the new boards, membrane and flashing in a repair are done to today's Code. Ask the contractor to check whether the boards themselves are sound, whether the sheathing membrane and any flashing behind them are intact, and whether the sheathing is solid. If the damage is limited to a few boards, ask for a price on replacing them with matching wood. Drop, lapped and vertical lumber siding must be at least 14.3 mm thick (9.27.6.2.).
If the assessment turns up widespread rot, failed membrane or damaged sheathing, ask for a full re-side price as well. For a heritage property, the material choice matters: tell the City's heritage staff what you are proposing; replacing original wood with a different material may affect heritage attributes and require a heritage permit. A staff-level heritage alteration permit is $309.00, though restoration and preservation projects meeting the Standards and Guidelines are fee-exempt. Ask the heritage staff which category your project falls into before budgeting.
Whatever the scope, the 2024 Ontario Building Code requires the wall to have two planes of protection: the cladding itself as the first plane, and a sheathing membrane conforming to CAN/CGSB-51.32-M as the second, with joints lapped not less than 100 mm and upper sheets overlapping lower ones (9.27.3.2., 9.27.3.3.). Flashing is required at horizontal junctions in the cladding, and over a wall opening where the vertical distance from the bottom of the eave to the top of the trim is more than one-quarter of the eave's overhang (9.27.3.8.). Sealant goes between the siding and window or door frames (9.27.4.). Wood cladding must sit not less than 200 mm above finished grade and not less than 50 mm above any roof surface (9.27.2.4.). Health Canada advises that a house built before 1960 probably contains lead-based paint, and one built between 1960 and 1990 may; do not sand or use heat to remove old paint, and have the wall tested before work begins.
Ask any contractor quoting this job to itemize: assessment of the substrate and membrane, matching lumber sourcing, removal and disposal of old material, membrane and flashing work, trim and corner details, and what happens to the price if more damage is found once the old boards come off. Ask for a WSIB clearance certificate and confirm the crew's Working at Heights training is current.
Keep the written contract, the itemized quote, the manufacturer's warranty on any new materials, and photos of the wall taken before anything is covered over: those records are worth having if a question comes up later about what was done and what was found.
What it costs: Siding repair
Want this done at your place?
Tell us about your siding and we'll send it to local Ottawa siding contractors, who reply by email. We send it out to local contractors for you. Free, no pressure.
Siding IQ -- Built from the Ontario Building Code, Ontario regulations and City of Ottawa sources and real construction experience. Answers are for informational purposes only and are not a professional assessment.
Ready to Get Quotes?
Find local siding contractors in Ottawa. Free matching, no obligation.